so what attracts you to the marlin 30-30 ?
Well, I didn't buy mine. My dad found a barely used one somewhere at a good price and with some pretty interesting figure in the stocks. Being a sucker for wood, he and my mom bought it for me for Christmas in 1976.
I wanted a Ruger No.1 but they never were exactly cheap and when my dad asked me what I might want for my first rifle, I said I wanted a light bolt action .243. I really didn't have any independent desire for the .30-30 lever action. But that's what I got.
My dad reckoned that when I got older and bought my own guns, I'd still find a use for a "thutty-thutty" and he was right about that. During a period when it wasn't my main squeeze huntin' rifle, I still found a use for it from time to time and was glad I had it when I did use it. Mostly, and probably not surprisingly, I used the hell out of it when hunting from my mare that I had back then. In my adulthood, I wound up taking seven of the 14 elk I've shot with center-fire rifles with that Marlin, mostly because it "rode on the horse" so well.
I'm really grateful that I DIDN'T get the .243 bolt action I THOUGHT I wanted as kid. The .30-30 very clearly does have limitations and few would have used it on the open terrain I generally hunted on as a kid, opting instead for flatter-shooting rounds with more range. But I firmly believe that having to work within those limitations made me a much better hunter than I would have been otherwise, and most definitely a "cooler-headed, more calculating" shooter in the field. While it had limitations, I can't say that they caused me to not fill a tag because they never have.
The .30-30 proved really, really versatile, too. When it was the ONLY rifle I had, I used it for all kinds of hunting, including shooting cottontails and pigmy hares on the California high desert. The point of that was to have something left to eat, and here, the .30-30 was awesome because I could shoot reduced loads in it capped by cast bullets that punched .308" holes but didn't ruin much of a bunny for eating. I thought the ability of the .30-30 to take small edible game with the right load was just uber-cool and it made the rifle really versatile to me.
The more I used it, the more I liked it. It was always fun to shoot. And even though magazine pundits said a .30-30 lever action wasn't accurate, mine was. It had a really crisp, light, creep-free trigger, too. That made it easy to shoot accurately. It was a joy to carry without being so light as to be hard to aim in the field. And it got on target like nothing else, having very shotgun-like handling dynamics.
Being in .30-30, it shot flat enough
most of the time and hit hard enough
all of the time. One thing I came to never worry about with the .30-30 was penetration. 170 grain bullets with their relatively high sectional densities and modest impact velocities would penetrate better than a glance at a ballistics table gave them any right to. When I started hunting pigs around the age of 16, I gained a whole other level of appreciation for .30-30 penetration and killing power.
Still, when I turned 18, I wanted
just a little more range and power.... A max range of 300 yards, instead of 200.... A little more thump for bigger critters like elk...
I spent a lot of my life thinking the 336 might well be the perfect hunting rifle if it only had a little more range and a little more power....
And with the advent of Hornady's LeveRevolution rounds and components to duplicate them through hand-loading, the .30-30 now has the trajectory and terminal ballistics to let me take deer-sized game as far off as I care to shoot at them, which for me is about 300 yards. Where I wouldn't think of using it as an elk gun absent hunting from a horse, I definitely would now. Those gummy-tips and that LVR powder give me
just that little bit extra in terms of performance that I wanted for so long. And I still enjoy the relatively mild recoil, ease of reloading, and rifle and cartridge symbiosis that I always have.
So I have come full-circle. I started with the .30-30 in a 336 and used it a lot when it was my only rifle. Now, it is not my only rifle, but with the LeveRevolution loads, it's all the rifle I really need in terms of range and killing power and nothing I don't in terms of recoil and muzzle blast. I use my .30-30 a lot more than my other big game hunting rifles (Ruger No.1 in .30-'06, Ruger M77RL in .250 Savage) during the hunting seasons.