Marlin Firearms Forum banner

Porcupine roast

6.4K views 34 replies 23 participants last post by  mooosie  
#1 ·
I hate the idea of killing an animal that I'm not going to eat. I shot a porcupine yesterday, so with great care I skinned him then quartered him. I looked and looked, but I couldn't find a recipe for porcupine that looked any good, so I invented my own. Its a WIP (Work In Progress), so it could use some adjustment, but it was good.

I brined the meat for 12 hours, which left it too salty for my (and my daughter's) liking. Next time I will only brine for 6 hours. I roasted the quartered legs and the abdominal and pectorial meat in a glass casserole dish with 3 carrots, 1/2 an onion, 1/2 a red pepper, some canned mushrooms, cracked pepper, garlic powder, and some onion soup mix. I used 1/2 the water that the soup mix called for, and that seemed just right. Temp was 350, time was 80 min, and I turned the meat once. I don't know anything about porcupine, so I wanted it well done. 80 minutes was too long though. If I cook one again I may try 60 minutes, or more likely, I will slow cook it with all the same ingredients.

The meat was very tender, but there is a lot of silverskin, which makes it seem tougher and stringier than it really is. maybe a slow cooker will have a better chance of melting that stuff off, or at least tenderizing it. The vegetables and soup mix were just right though. The flavor was delicious. It tasted a lot like a beef pot roast, but had some flavor like a squirrel too. The onions and peppers were great with the meat's own flavor, and the carrots added familiarity to the pot roastie-ness of it. I will definitely not hesitate to shoot and eat another one.
 
#3 ·
That's a first for me. Way to go pokey.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pokey
#5 ·
Porcupine have to be the dumbest animal on God's earth but Lord, they are destructive of trees. Here in North dakota, trees are scarce and porcupine is not. I shoot a number of them each year and have heard tell that they are good to eat; decent survival food at least. Your recipe sounds good except for the carrots, yuck.
 
#9 ·
Porcupine have to be the dumbest animal on God's earth but Lord, they are destructive of trees. Here in North dakota, treeare scarce and porcupine is not. I shoot a number of them each year and have heard tell that they are good to eat; decent survival food at least. Your recipe sounds good except for the carrots, yuck.
If they aren't dumb, then they're deaf & blind and lack a sense of smell.

I suppose you could substitute turnips for carrots if you don't mind people thinking that you're some kind of weirdo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BloodGroove4570
#10 ·
I rarely see them, but all I've ever done is just watch them walk by... :biggrin:
 
#11 ·
When i was younger a friend's father cooked porcine and it was delicious. He was from Newfoundland, i don't know if the recipe was from here or there, what spices he used i don't know but he stuck salt pork to it with toothpicks and cooked it really slow. And my god it was delicious.
 
#12 ·
OP, unless you're doing to fry the meat, ala fried chicken, I'd skip the brining altogether. Also, the excess saltiness may have been caused by the soup mix, which is very high in sodium.

I don't know if slow cooking will "dissolve" silver skin. You may need to remove it with a really sharp knife.

Next time, I'd season the parts with salt and pepper (and maybe even some onion and garlic powder), dredge them in a little flour, and then brown them. Substitute some beef or chicken stock for the water and soup mix, and use it to deglaze the skillet you used for browning. Get a heavy casserole or cast iron dutch oven that's just big enough for your meat and vegetables, and has a cover. Put your vegetables and meat in the pan, and pour the stock from the skillet in.

Cover the casserole, and cook everything at 325 until your meat is tender.
 
#15 ·
OP, unless you're doing to fry the meat, ala fried chicken, I'd skip the brining altogether. Also, the excess saltiness may have been caused by the soup mix, which is very high in sodium.

I don't know if slow cooking will "dissolve" silver skin. You may need to remove it with a really sharp knife.

Next time, I'd season the parts with salt and pepper (and maybe even some onion and garlic powder), dredge them in a little flour, and then brown them. Substitute some beef or chicken stock for the water and soup mix, and use it to deglaze the skillet you used for browning. Get a heavy casserole or cast iron dutch oven that's just big enough for your meat and vegetables, and has a cover. Put your vegetables and meat in the pan, and pour the stock from the skillet in.

Cover the casserole, and cook everything at 325 until your meat is tender.
Thank you for the tips. I may be kick-banned from the forum for saying this, but I don't own a cast iron skillet. It's probably time to get one though.
Doesn't porcupine just beg to be shish kabobbed over an open fire?
Haha! Yes, it does seem that way.
Sounds like you should cook it in a pot with a rock. When the rock is soft,throw out the porcupine and eat the rock.
Did you read that on a bumper sticker?
 
  • Like
Reactions: deerhog
#18 ·
Try armadillo. Its pretty good. Stand in an electric skillet put some water in then let simmer till the white n dark meat seperate. Or ya can parboil kt then dredge in flour n fry. Only seasonins I use are a lil salt lil garlic n a bit of black pepper. I've et ****, possum, turtle, beaver, house cat, armadillo, gar, and a few others that don't come to mind right off.
I'm with the op ifn I kill it I'm at least gonna try to eat it.
 
#21 ·
Everyone needs some cast iron! Anyways, cook it in a slow cooker or low and slow in the oven covered. The silver skin will dissolve over time. I cook venison shanks this way. And there is no way the porcupine has more silver skin than a venison shank. And by the way, once those shanks are done they are some of the finest eating meat on the animal. I can only surmise its the way the muscles are arranged. Tender beyond belief with an fantastic texture. Again I believe its because of the muscle arrangement. I may have to try a porcupine now! Thanks for the recipe
 
#22 ·
I was reading through this thread and my wife said, "Ask if anybody's tried armadillo!" and lo and behold somebody has! Glad to hear rattlesnake doesn't taste like chicken but I'm glad someone else discovered that fact:biggrin: John
 
#24 · (Edited)
One overlooked aspect of porcupine as survival food...they are so slow you don't need to shoot em. Haven't seen one in a long time, but we used to just hit em with a rock or club. Roll em over in a fire to singe dull the quills, skin em and roast em on a hot rock next to the fire. Seemed kinda pork-like at the time...had teeth, then, too. That helped a lot.

Hey Pard...somehow I missed yer post whilst typing mine. All I can say is, we were hunting, and if maybe not exactly lost (whoever wants to admit that?) we were a mite challenged directionally and conserving ammo.
 
#25 ·
Racoon down here in E-Texas is considered a delicacy by black folks. They pay 20 to 25 dollars for one in a heartbeat. I know several **** hunters that sell everyone they catch. They called the Armadillo during the depression a Hoover hog and lots of folks ate them. I have never tried rattlesnake and do not plan to, got to draw the line somewhere. I have seen them skinned and cooked but never partook.
 
#26 ·
I've had racoon that was parboiled, then slow oven roasted. It was kind of sweet and stringy, but tender, like a good brisket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marlin .45 carbine
#29 ·
Sorry, I'm not going to tangle with a porcupine. I don't fool around with armadillos or opossums either. I prefer venison and pork. Squirrel is pretty good too.
Lately, I am getting the urge to have some crappy fillets.
I've had some of those at Golden Corral.
 
#31 ·
Porcupines & beaver can save your life in the bush if you're lost.
They're relatively plentiful, not hard to catch and the meat is fat and full of calories and protein.
Your body doesn't get much of a head of steam from eating grouse & rabbit flesh but they're better than nothing.
A friend of dads was lost in the woods near Kenora, Ontario in Canada for 5 days back in the 70s and made a meal of a coupla ruffed grouse & a beaver he had shot in the head with his Cooey 22LR rifle.
Porcupines & beaver are mother natures emergency food packs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Standup2p