if this has been posted, I'm slow ...
Oh my Matlin instead of Marlin .... Old man with fat fingers and a Smart Phone ��
I recall Jimmy Carter was threatened by a mad Rabbit!...............he could have needed a gun like that!..........LOL!!This last year was my 43 year deer hunting,only one time in all those years did a brother in law bring an AR-15 to deer camp,always is a good shot every other year,that year he shot at least 8 times,never found a deer until after deer season,found 3 through out the woods dead,not my idea of a good time,not my idea of a good,or even a needed weapon for hunting,its only design was to shoot lots of bullets at everything and kill people.I have never felt threatened in any way by a deer,squirrel,rabbit,or grouse,never had a need to carry an assault or black rifle.We have a new camp rule since that season,no assault weapons in camp by anyone,nothing my father or grandfather would not have called a deer rifle.I do like wood and blued steel,were not shooting the enemy or aliens in my camp,at least not yet just my opinion
Your post lost all credibility comparing a 60 grain 223 partition to a 150 grain 30-06 load. Its an apples to tiny grapes comparison. Not even fair to compare the twoLots of animosity towards AR15s and the .223 Rem. Those complaining are to me just as bad as those who are too inept to use them properly. The problem is not with using a 223 for deer, it's using FMJ or varmint bullets for deer. Both wound deer, with varmint bullets often making craters that cause a needless, lingering, suffering death. Nosler makes a 60gr Partician bullet specifically for this purpose, and for those who don't reload, Federal offers loaded ammo. Terminal performance (ie meat, heart, lung and bone) damage is on a par with some 150gr 30-06 loads, though at closer ranges. And speaking of bullet failures, I had a 100gr 25-06 Rem Core-Lokt fail on a doe at 364 yards (my buddy measured it with a laser). The bullet entered behind the left shoulder and exited the right haunch. It never expanded. Might as well have used a long 1/4" drill rod. The bullet even went through the liver and never damaged it. Classic bullet failure. Yet no one blames my Browning 1885 Single Shot nor the 25-06 cartridge for this failure.
As for the AR15, it's simply a gun. One that is very user friendly for customization for ergonomics, instead of a one-size-fits-none stock as most 'sporting' rifles have. The AR15 is also available in other cartridges, some more suitable for deer hunting. And its big brother, the AR10, comes in popular deer cartridges like the .243 Win and .308 Win.
Having said that, for big game I prefer lever actions and single shots, from 30-30 to 30-06 to 45-70.
For coyote hunting, my main coyote rifle is an AR15, but for many years I used Browning 1885 Single Shot High Walls in 223, 22-250 and 25-06. Restoring a Win 1895 in 25-35 for close to medium range coyotes.
Everyone likes their own cup of tea, but there's no need to run down what the other guy is drinking, and no need to condemn cartridges or guns because one boob used the wrong bullet and can't place his shots. Because you'd have to condemn nearly every sporting rifle and cartridge if you do that.
Back on topic, re: Marlin 336 Dark, not my cup of tea. I prefer my lever guns more traditional. I do have a Marlin 1895 GSBL with the green stock. This is the stainless version with a black finish. I wanted an all weather gun, but am in the process of putting well sealed traditional walnut stocks on it. The 336 Dark appears to just be matte black carbon steel. If it was blackened stainless I think it would be a winner for a non-shiny all weather gun.
I have. I'll passIt's obvious from your post that you have not personally seen the damage level; I have.
Also note I included a range limitation. That Partition bullet is incapable of matching the 30-06 for range. It is a close range bullet. To be specific, the damage you see a 30-06 do at longer distances is matched short range by the 60 gr Partition. But it cannot match the 30-06 at the same medium or long range.
This is something that many hunters don't think about. We hear tale of how their favorite big game cartridge/bullet did at 200 to 400 yards, then turn around and poo-poo a lesser round at close range. Yet they don't bother to stop and think that the short range cartridge is matching velocity or kinetic energy , but at a closer range.
Lever Addict,I guess they had to figure out how to use all those crappy stocks they made since the take over. Just coat em in bed liner paint! Call it the dark series!