Marlin Firearms Forum banner

.45-70 versus Dinosaurs

1 reading
7.6K views 45 replies 27 participants last post by  speydude  
#1 ·
I haven't watched the newer dinosaur adventure movies but I caught a little bit of one of the newer flicks. I sure have fallen behind in my dinosaur viewing pleasure. Currently kind of laid up with a pinched nerve in my back. So I was moseying around on the You Tube videos where I saw a segment showing the hero running around with a Marlin .45-70. Presumably that rifle would be his protection from the Hollywood style super monster T-Rex. Now I happen to have four .45-70 rifles, I shot deer and wild hogs with my .45-70s. I know how the .45-70 with 305 grain hollow points and 400 grain soft points performs on deer and hogs. BUT -- a .45-70 versus a super monster T-Rex, or even a more realistic paleontologist's T-Rex -- I don't think so but maybe I am wrong.

Getting to the "wild game" question, however, saying that a real T-Rex was causing predatory damage to a person's herd of cattle, what caliber and load should be recommended to bring down a T-Rex? Where to place the shot, and so on? Would a shot in a knee cap at least knock a T-Rex down? There's so many questions that come to my mind as I lay here with a knocked out back.
 

Attachments

#2 ·
IDK, but I suspect a 50cal BMG would piss it off. I'd rather have a 20mm to reach it's vitals. Regardless, just in case it didn't work, I want some kind of vehicle at ready to escape quick. LOL

The Raptors, 45-70 would probably take care of but I'd want M134.

Jack
 
#4 ·
If ya can sneak up on em and shine a lite in their eyes, they freeze up for a moment. 22lr right behind the ear. Drops 'em every time.
 
#6 ·
I am a geologist with minors in paleontology and zoo. One way to consider a T-Rex or similar critter is that they were giant chickens, with big teeth and probably a bad attitude. Their bones were at least partially hollow so despite being quite large, they were not all that heavily built as some might consider. A Bear Load .45-70 should put one down. But to stop a charging T-Rex I would want Ruger to make me a lever gun in .577 Tyrannosaur and since that is a 60,000 psi cartridge making over 10,000 fpe we gonna need a new action considerably stronger than an 1895 and probably a gas piston recoil control in the stock so that it does not dislocate or break the shoulder.
 
#12 ·
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/73/cf/ae/73cfae593467f951342db0b36e42a9e6--dinosaurs-jokes.jpg
Save

Or just wait around a bit.
 
#14 ·
I’m not formally educated in dinosaurs, but like many young boys I studied ALL things dinosaur. And a previous comment nailed it, they’re basically big chickens. Raptors weren’t near the size portrayed in the movies either. If you hit the field with your .30-06 or .45-70 a T-Rex would be no problem. And some 3.5” magnum 00 Buck out of a 12 gauge would probably liquify a velociraptor, but the other 6-7 would continue being a problem
 
#20 ·
Apparently cosplay is a thing and I did not even know what it was, had to look it up. People dress up as popular characters including all of the accouterment. Weird, I have a hard enough time being me. Chris Pratt is one of the guys all of the simps want to be and here is their carry rifle for cosplay for Jurassic Park and Chris Pratt:




I dunno, something seems missing (n).
 
#32 ·
The jury is out on how fast a T-Rex could run. Somewhere between 15MPH and 35MPH but with much disagreement. Nobody would think, never having seen a living bear, just by looking at the bones how fast they can run or how agile they are. I suspect there would be some surprises if we ever do get to meet up with a T-Rex or any of it's dino mates.

Still, if I had time to dump a full magazine tube of Garrett Penetrators in the darn thing I think it would know something bad had just happened.
 
#35 ·
(Hypothetical Game) Using a Barrett 107A1: Multiple, well placed hits with a RAUFOSS MK211 rounds could work.
Theory: T-Rex can't chase and eat you if the leg joints and eyes are destroyed...

Sure, The Marlin .45-70 with the right load could work too. But I wouldn't want to be that close to it to find out I was wrong. No, I'll stick with the Barrett 107A1 and several mags of the MK211 rounds. :rolleyes:

Old Creek
 
#37 ·
Still and all, I have to lay here with the back pains and pains in the left arm and I have to wonder about that one (the second dino movie ?) in which there was a bald guy with a really nice looking double rifle. I never learned from the movie what caliber it was. It looked like something about a .470 Nitro Express, something like that. A big British piece of artillery. However, since then I have watched some YouTube videos about .45-70 technically improved bullets and loads being tested against old and rancid pork butt meat. Wow, the solid brass projectiles with hot loads are really something to see in action.
 
#38 ·
I never learned from the movie what caliber it was. It looked like something about a .470 Nitro Express, something like that
There is an IMDB style website that is a huge database of guns in movies. For instance, if you want to know what guns were used in A Fist Full of Dollars, or a list of movies and TV shows where a Steyer AUG was used, that can be easily found out. it's called IMFDB or Internet Movie Firearms Database.