Marlin Firearms Forum banner

1904 Marlin 1893 .38-55 - What Is She Worth?

16K views 18 replies 16 participants last post by  sargemarlin  
#1 ·
Can ya'll help me for a good friend of mine needs a typical buy price on a very nice condition 1904 Marlin 1893 in .38-55 octagon barrel . . Very nice wood and very very nice metal and action. Overall this gun is a good 95% condition. I can tell you the owner is asking in the neighborhood of $2000 for it.

Thanks,

GB45
 
  • Like
Reactions: erimort
#3 ·
Bore is also very good. Do not have any pictures as of yet - my friend has seen the rifle and described it to me. He is a knowledgeable buyer/owner of many fine guns but does not have the knowledge of Marlins yet. The 1893 is his to purchase but he must give the owner a final answer and buy it by Monday evening or it will be sold to others who have made offers so he asked me to check with our M.O. team for an answer. If he buys it there will be pictures.

GB45
 
#5 ·
Does it say 1893 and not 93? For 2 Grand on a 1893 I would expect a near safe queen with case coloring on the reciever and lever. Ive seen really nice examples go for 1300-1500 bucks! Oh and thats on GB! The case should have good color...not like new but... not traces or reminants! The wood should have no repairs, not refinished with serial #'s matching the gun. The butt plate has a ser# also! Fairly flawless wood to metal fit on those original stocks too! The barrel hopefully special smokeless steel with decent to good blue, rollstamps not worn and ledgible. The corners of the octagon not dinged and sharp. Original sights front and rear! Good bore? The full octagon was the most common 1893 made. 38-55 is one of the more desirable calibers. Round barrels or half round half oct are more rare! Its really hard to say without seeing it, but these are some things to look for. It does seem a little high to me, BUT...i'm sure somewhere...somebody...has a beautiful specimen thats been sitting in the family closet for generations! These fine examples are getting extremly hard to come by and are being bought up by collectors! Get em while you can or while you can afford them!
 
#6 ·
I would agree to all the postings above. For that kind of money it would have to be very clean, original, have nice case coloring, and a "smokeless steel" barrel. If he is looking to buy this as a "shooter" I would thing $1,500 is about right. If looking for a "safe queen" investment then $2,000 would not be out of line. There are only so many available and haven't been made in a very long time, and few if any prospects of amy more being made in the future in that caliber. Shenandoah
 
#8 ·
Lou,

Don't forget what you explained to me before as well, about not having any signature plates or anything of that nature attached to the wood.

John
 
#9 ·
Mr. Golfbuddy45: Since no one else mentioned special order features, I thought I'd add my 2 cents since these dramatically increase the price: (1). pistol gripped, instead of straight grip. (2). longer or shorter barrel than normal 26" length. (3). already mentioned 1/2 round, 1/2 octagonal barrel. (3). checkering. (4). select grain/fancy wood. (5). rear tang sight. (6). front globe sight. (7). provenance it belonged to a historical figure.
These features must be factory original. Overall condition of the gun is most paramount.
Good luck! Hang-Fire Hank
 
#10 ·
Mr. Golfbuddy45: Since no one else mentioned special order features, I thought I'd add my 2 cents since these dramatically increase the price: (1). pistol gripped, instead of straight grip. (2). longer or shorter barrel than normal 26" length. (3). already mentioned 1/2 round, 1/2 octagonal barrel. (3). checkering. (4). select grain/fancy wood. (5). rear tang sight. (6). front globe sight. (7). provenance it belonged to a historical figure.
These features must be factory original. Overall condition of the gun is most paramount.
Good luck! Hang-Fire Hank

Yes there are many things to take into consideration!
 
#12 · (Edited)
Hey guys im new to marlin owners ..i just got a 1893 special smokless steel 38.55 on trade for a Taurus 24/7 pro .40 . Im pretty sure i got a killer deal because the gun is in great shape and the bore is still shiny and can see the rifling great. No rust or pitting. Alot of color on the barrel and case!! What do yall think?? Serial number 252*** i think its around 1902. !
]
 

Attachments

#18 ·
you should be locked up for robbery! that's a nice one!
Hey guys im new to marlin owners ..i just got a 1893 special smokless steel 38.55 on trade for a Taurus 24/7 pro .40 . Im pretty sure i got a killer deal because the gun is in great shape and the bore is still shiny and can see the rifling great. No rust or pitting. Alot of color on the barrel and case!! What do yall think?? Serial number 252*** i think its around 1902. ! View attachment 137329 View attachment 137331 View attachment 137332 View attachment 137334 ]
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbavar904
#16 ·
Beware of the famous buyers in waiting threat, that's usually used to make you make a rushed and over valued offer.eh