A hooded front sight comes from a time when many rifles were carried in saddle scabbards. "Winged" front sights are mostly window dressing on non military rifles but use a rifle in combat and the real "wings" proove their worth.
I chose the Brockman Winged front and rear for my Guide Gun. Quick pick up with the rear peep. Have not had the opportunity to kill anything with it yet but don't foresee any issues. This set up was chosen because of the adjustability. I shoot a wide range of hand loads.
Another winged Brockman sight user here. The wings don't seem to bother my view, but I doubt I would miss them much either, haven't droped my rifle on a rock lately....they are fully adjustable, and I do like that.
FWIW I can tell you from experience that it is no fun having your rifle fall over and the top of the front sight snap off during a hunt/hunting season. I doubt many carry a spare front sight around with them on a hunt.
if my rifle fell over so hard it snapped the front sight I'd be very worried... Mine is low tensile steel and wouldn't snap if I hit it with a hammer (might bend a bit), but seriously other I'd be worried about other damage.
I think winged front sights look crap personally but hooded ones are different, almost of even. So long as the dovetail is tight I don't see the need. Maybe it snags on clothing less?