Marlin Firearms Forum banner

1 - 18 of 18 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hi. I have a questionabout a Marlin Model 27, 25-20 pump.

I have one of these pieces that I'm trying to establish a general value for.The condition is somewhere between G & VG - but certainly not factoryshinny. Still, it is over a hundred years old. The parts are original and ingood shape. The stock and forearm are in decent condition - the forearm has aslight crack between the screw heads but both pieces look very good. The screwsare intact and not missing or reamed out. The octagon barrel is inscribed"Special Smokeless Steel". Question:This appears to be a take-apart model... were there any of these or were theyall take-apart?

I've had this piece since the mid 70's - got it from a distant relative butdon't know any of the history behind it.

Anyone care to give a high/low price that you've seen these sell for in thelast few years?

Thanks,
Max
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
639 Posts
Hello and WELCOME to the MarlinOwners forum, IMO its the best forum on the web for anything dealing with shooting.. :congrats:

I'm sorry I don't have the answers you are looking for. :hmmmm:

The thing about this forum is the members here each have a great amount of knowledge but when you combine all of them in one place, will its a wonderful place to seek and get answers, find friends and just associate and converse with some really good down to earth, fine Folk's. :tee:

I am sure other members will be along shortly with the answers your questions. :)

Again Welcome Aboard...!!! :biggrin:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
484 Posts
Max,

Well I also don't have all of the answers that you are looking for. But I will tell you what I know about my Marlin 27S.

Notice mine is a 27S and I think that you only mentioned yours being a model 27. So yours is probably older. If I remember correctly my 27S was made in the late WW1 timeframe, 1917 or 1918.

I paid $300 for my .25-20 model 27S oh about 5 years ago. I bought mine cuz it was in VERY good shape.

Upon learning more I realize that while mine was in great shape, great blueing, original stocks, everything is original except there was some sort of OLD aftermarket rear sight where the Hepburn rear sight was supposed to go! So that DECREASES value and desireability!

I wish mine had the old Rky Mtn rear sight.

So from what I've heard lately, for a Model 27 like you describe, probably less than the $300 I paid for mine.

You will find on these forums, guys like pictures to help in describing condition and value.

If you post some pictures some of the real experts will probably chime in with a $$$ number in mind.

By the way, I really like the .25-20 cartridge! I've got two of them, a Winchester 1892 to go along with the 27S and that .25-20 cartridge is very handy and versatile! Great choice for ground squirrels, rock chucks and coyotes out to 100 yrds or so.

That's my 2 cents worth and like others said, WELCOME ABOARD!

GEOFF
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
GEOFF,
Thanks. That gets me started. Certainly, the value depends on many things and varies with condition, who, when and where (beauty is in the eye of the beholder - or in this case the holder - HA!). Yes, I should have included pictures - didn't think about that - try to do that next time. Again, I sure appreciate your input.

It's good to find a site of Marlin enthusiasts.

Max
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
i haven't seen one go for less than 400, in the last couple of years, and i watch a lot of auctions. i have one myself....really like it.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
484 Posts
It's great to see the 27 and 27S getting a little more respect out there!!

For quite a while they didn't seem to attract much interest and I kinda thought maybe I'd overpaid for mine at $300.

Maybe a good lesson, one might overpay a bit at time of purchase, but as the years slide by, it makes the deal look a lot better.

Thanks for the price info above.

GEOFF
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,672 Posts
Maybe a good lesson, one might overpay a bit at time of purchase, but as the years slide by, it makes the deal look a lot better.
Yep, I bought my 1894 CCL in 2000 for what at the time seemed like an outrageous price. Everyone that knew what I paid for it thought I was nuts and to be honest, I was kind of wondering myself. Since then, I've seen 'em sell for over twice what I paid for mine on Gunbroker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GEOFF

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
484 Posts
44-40 Willy,

Good to see your post! You are another one of the old timers that probably remembers the old Marlin Talk. Remember the old Marlin company owned/run site??? That was a sad day when they said Marlin no longer wanted the site. Then we went to Marlin owners! What a job they've done over the years, what, over 20,000 members. Good to see!

Glad to see these Marlins holding their value. The first Marlin I ever bought was an 1897Texan about the same time frame as you are talking. I'll have to track some of those on Gunbroker, and see how they are doing!

GEOFF
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Looked for 25-20 WCF on line and at gun-shows for about 6 months. No Winchesters to be found for less than $1,400. Did find some Remington Model 25s in that caliber, but not for less than $950.00 in decent shape. Marlin Model 27s in 25-20 were going for not less than $850.00 to $950.00 in good condition. I finally found one for $650, where the buttstock had been replaced, but bore was a little rough. Bought it, and found the bore was just merely leaded badly. Cleaned it up and it's a good shooter.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Marlin 25-20

JUST READ YOUR NOTE: MAYBE SOMEONE CAN ANSWER ME ON THIS QUESTION?
I HAVE A 27S .25 CA. RF. PRETTY DIFFICULT TO FIND AMMO AND ITS MISSING ITS FIRING PIN.
I READ THAT THE GUN CAN BE CONVERTED TO A .25-20 BY REPLACING THE BREACH, FIRING PIN(Cf)
AND BORE THE THE BARREL TP .25-20.IS THIS TRUE AND GIVE ME YOUR THOUGHTS?
IF THIS IS TRUE, IS IT EASY TO FIND .25-20 AMMO?
THANKS,
TODD
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
Hi Gang...I saw one in a Gun Trader just over a year ago for $900 I called immediately...GONE! it was listed in Very Good condx with 1 bx of ammo 46 rounds-4 missing...btw I have seen Stevens long Rifle 65 gr. ammo for...ready...$6.00 EACH round! But have not seen a 27-S or ANY AMMO now listed anywhere. I happen to have one in the same or better than good condx with a 10 x scope and a bx of shorts. Have been think of selling...but not sure how much mine is worth?
Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
@ Todd...the easiest is to take the old firing pin to a machinest who can do CNC or Hi-pressure water cutting.
Take both an old 25 RF and a 25 CF and have them cut NEW FIRING PIN designed for the center fire. At least that way CF ammo is available and you can shoot. Keep both firing pins....if the gun is in better than fair condx or better it will sell for over $600.
Next to impossible to find .25 cal RF ammo...I posted above that the last time i saw Stevens Long Rifle 65 gr. ammo it was selling for $6.00 each round The 27-S will shoot both short and Long Rifle rounds.
Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
579 Posts
27s

Just gave 625.00 for mine two weeks ago. Super shooter. I am really pleased. Later, moodyholler
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
8906_313927742050777_1981544433_n.jpg
I have had one of these for years.... in decent condition.... are you guys saying it may be worth something .... Ive kept it clean and is a straight shooter.....
but I brought it into a gun store once and he was going to give me 100 bucks for it
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
279 Posts
I have a Marlin 27S in 25-20 that is in excellent shape including bore and Shoots well >its a fun gun Only problem is, with an oversize chamber it splits Brass, Which I ve heard is fairly common with these. Anyone else have this problem? A friend has one and his isnt as bad on brass

Phil
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Top