I would vote for a new stock and forearm if it were mine, some trace of the fix will always be there, and most of all it would be in my mind that I dropped the rifle and split it. And now i have a Marlin with a repaired stock, cover it and no one knows it, but i know it. I would rather spend time on a new stock, then repairing the old one that`s always going to be split. Just my thinking. :hmmmm: