It is not so much nostalgia, but rather that of using a bullet, Wide Flat Nose here, that is extremely effective.
No need to use warp speeds, mid 1000 - 2000fps will simply get er done.
Using a cast bullet in the 450, would be little different then using one in any other cartridge of .44 cal or larger.
Get the correct bore to bullet fit, and develop a good load with a good bullet cast of a good alloy and in the 45cal. something of over 400gr and you simply have an extremely effective tool for taking anything that walks North American and most of the rest of the world.
The 465gr at 1650fps from my 45/70 is so awesome on deer and elk, that I wish I would have started this journey at a much younger age!
I have 4 different cast bullets for hunting with my .450 Marlin.
350gr Ranch Dog
400gr BABore GCHP
420gr. BABore GCWN
420gr. Ranch Dog
Any one of them would kill anything on the continent. The 350gr has been used on deer. VERY effective. The 420gr Ranch Dog actually shoots better in my rifle than the 350gr but the 350 is a bit flatter shooting. Still working on finding "The Load" for the other two. I've got enough points to draw the Michigan Bear Tag of my choice so when I decide to make the move, it'll be one of the BABore bullets up the pipe.
I have a couple hundred RP 300gr. JHPs on the shelf. Also very effective on deer- maybe too much. Loaded to 450 velocities it is really destructive. It's designed for .45-70 TD velocities but if I'd wanted a 45-70 TD I would have bought one.
To me there's just something special about taking game with bullets you made yourself in loads you developed yourself. The 450 (and the 45-70) are calibers that are perfect for big, heavy cast flying hammerheads! :biggrin:
I also have a Lee 400 PB mold that I load to about 1000-1100 fps. Great loads for plinking! Very accurate, soft recoil, inexpensive and fun to shoot. It would also be an effective hunting load but the trajectory is more mortar-like than I prefer. It's kind of wild to shoot at the steel deer we have on our range (88 yards) and hear "Boom.....Whack!" LOL
I really hope the 450 gains some ground in popularity. Not in a position yet to start reloading again however the 450 will definately be on the list. I have two 45-70's and one 450 that I took out for the first time this year. Love it, love it, love it!!!
I found seven boxes of the full length cases in Hornady 350 JFP ammo last year when I bought the gun. Since then I have gone through three boxes and assorted reloads. I was set to use factory 350 JFP for hunting season this year again but changed my mind and sighted the gun in for a Speer 300 JFP over top a full charge of Re7. It clocks 2129 fps and shoots right around 1 1/2" group at 100 yards.
Around me, I can find the LE ammo but not the full length stuff (350 JFP) at a reasonable price ($35-40) so I keep the remaining four boxes as a reserve. Who knows when I will run into a fellow 450 guy who needs ammo. I have never seen just brass. I know of a shop towards Gettysburg that had ten boxes of the 350s in stock but he wanted $50 a box. Too rich for me.
As CDOC stated, components are sometimes hard to find for these fine, but odd-ball, guns. If you shoot one, you just need to always be on watch for components. Of course that can be taken too far as evidenced by the 300+ 50-70 cases I have. Including over 100 new, unfired Bell cases. Or the 600+ Hornady .338 200 JFP bullets, or... Well you get the idea.
I can see your point with the 50/70 as that may be a bit more exclusive club and limited market. However, with most components, it is hard to have too much or too many.
I figure it is a lot like money in the bank only better as money in the bank is simply a piece of paper with a promise to pay more paper, while many components have hard fast value. Trade em for a sack of spuds or a couple dozen eggs or -----------
Well you get the idea. Hard to make that trade with a piece of paper.
Wish you lived close, as I have a 465gr Wide Flat Nose cast bullet that your 450 just might love.
Way better then the 300 something "J" bullets and there is little need to push to the 2000 plus velocities.
Took one deer with a 355gr WFN cast bullet at 2300fps from my 45/70 and I never want to see that big of a wound channel again.
Can't see that a light for caliber bullet at over 2000fps would be any better from the 450 Marlin then it is from the 45/70.
Yep, we just might have some fun if you lived close by! :flute: