Marlin Firearms Forum banner

21 - 40 of 41 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,072 Posts
I'm a 1911, 45 ACP user. I've tried Glocks and just never liked the feel. That's purely subjective but isn't that what it's all about?

I wanted something MORE for the woods. My choice was a 10mm long slide from Kimber. The recoil and time to return to target are too much for my liking when compared to a 1911 in .45. However, those are not detrimental to woods carry, hunting, or bear defense. For those purposes the 10mm cartridge shines. So, while I do not recommend a 10mm for duty or concealed carry, it is THE auto cartridge for the outdoors.

The .40 S&W never appealed to me. Why would I want a weakened version of the 10mm downloaded for use by FBI lawyers and accountants, many of them female to-boot? I have always believed the .45 ACP is at least as good, if not better than, the .40 as a defensive cartridge regardless of "expert" opinion. Most recent "expert" FBI opinion is that the 9mm is better than either the .40 or the .45. So much for "expert" opinion!

Back to 10mm. It is a most excellent cartridge. It is both powerful and accurate. It remained in the background for decades but now the secret is out and it enjoys a very large and growing following. Ammo, yes ammo. There are many choices and they are loaded to a very wide range of velocities. I tested several factory loads. I posted this chart elsewhere but it deserves a place here as well. You won't see this kind of performance from any .40.

Remember, the test firearm, my pistol, has a 6" barrel.

10mmFactoryLoads.jpg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,457 Posts
Wasn't the 10mm first, and then the .40 S&W came later? Or am I mistaken?

Seems I read the 10mm was developed for the FBI, who then decided it was too powerful, so the .40S&W came about to tone it down some.....
Agents Dove and Grogan were killed in a serious shootout with some very skilled and well armed bad guys (Miami 1986). It was an engagement much examined by agencies all over the place after, including by me. Correct me if mistaken, its been a long time. It was a rolling stop of two armed bank robbers. I am pretty sure they had Min14s and handguns and used them to effect, lots of fire and movement. The FBI agents were outgunned and outclassed. Without going into the detail, and I remember quite a lot, the issue for the FBI was ineffective calibre's, especially 9mmP. The bad guys took hits and one in particular would surely die, but not before killing two agents. Hence they went looking for more effective calibre's.

If you google it I am sure you can read up on it, many lessons were learned. From the agent who removed his handgun and placed it on the car seat beside him, only to spend the entire engagement looking for it when it slipped away to the agent killed when he lost his glasses, and couldn't see the guy shooting at him. They had shotguns I think but no rifles. Obviously a long time ago, but the search for more effective calibre's and weapons followed.

I still have the after incident report somewhere. It actually makes sad reading. Pretty sure they made a movie about it, never saw it though.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,902 Posts
I started out with 10mm in the Smith & Wesson 610 with 4" barrel in 2004. Not being accustomed to N frame revolvers at the time it got traded off. Years since I sought out another 10mm. In January 2018 I purchased a Ruger SR 1911. It fit well in my stable of 1911's. Two months later an auction lot came up of two first year Kimber Custom II's. They came home and one is a 10mm. The 10mm's shoot fantastic. Far more recoil than any 1911 I've ever shot. The ejected cases go straight back between 15 and 20 feet. Both Sig Sauer and Fiocchi chronograph over the 1250 fps advertised velocity with a 180 grain bullet. Kimber on the left is the 10mm. One on the right is a 45.

20191120_114020.jpg 20180506_151511.jpg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,454 Posts
Agents Dove and Grogan were killed in a serious shootout with some very skilled and well armed bad guys (Miami 1986). It was an engagement much examined by agencies all over the place after, including by me. Correct me if mistaken, its been a long time. It was a rolling stop of two armed bank robbers. I am pretty sure they had Min14s and handguns and used them to effect, lots of fire and movement. The FBI agents were outgunned and outclassed. Without going into the detail, and I remember quite a lot, the issue for the FBI was ineffective calibre's, especially 9mmP. The bad guys took hits and one in particular would surely die, but not before killing two agents. Hence they went looking for more effective calibre's.

If you google it I am sure you can read up on it, many lessons were learned. From the agent who removed his handgun and placed it on the car seat beside him, only to spend the entire engagement looking for it when it slipped away to the agent killed when he lost his glasses, and couldn't see the guy shooting at him. They had shotguns I think but no rifles. Obviously a long time ago, but the search for more effective calibre's and weapons followed.

I still have the after incident report somewhere. It actually makes sad reading. Pretty sure they made a movie about it, never saw it though.
A number of the feebs were shooting 38 wheel guns. one of the bad guys took a 38 in his arm pit, which traveled straight to his heart. it proved to be fatal, but not for a minute or two in which time he was able to kill another agent or 3.

when i was a cadet in the houston police academy (1991, so miami was still pretty fresh), we studied that shooting in excruciating detail. if there was any way to screw up a particular aspect of that felony traffic stop, the feebs figured out a way to do it. it was (and still is) THE text book on how NOT to do things.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,116 Posts
I've had S&W M&P and Ruger in 40cal. Shot a box or two out of each at targets. Had Colt Delta Elite and shot less. My nephew just got a Kimber 10mm this summer for deer pistol. We've shot it a good bit at steel plates and target. Good shooting pistol. I hit groundhog silo at 100yds more times than I missed. Benched it shot like a rifle. We have dies but are still burning up factory ammo. I don't like the 40 at all.

I have watched reinactments of Dixie shoot out and LA Bank Robbery. The Dixie shoot out was spur of moment. No thought was given to shoot out. No only under gunned but under prepared and they knew what kind of hardware bad guys had. LA was a case of under gun. Many cops were scoring hits but perps had body armor. A SWAT guy would have folded both bad guys with 2 shots from a 308.
Watching those shootouts is as sickning as WW2 footage of Sherman tanks being shot to pieces by German Panzers. They didn't have a chance.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
18,009 Posts
A little clarification on the events of Miami 1986 seems due here, if I may.....this is from memory, so bear with me please.

Ben Grogan ran the FBI team that attempted to take down Platt and Matix via felony car-stop. The ensuing collision threw up a lot of dust, discombobulated several agents, and confusion reigned. Most of the FBI guys had 9mm's, which was the round eventually blamed for the "Failure" to kill the bad guys even though two "non-survivable" hits were scored on Michael Platt. The bigger problem was tactics, as Platt outmaneuvered the agents and killed Ben Grogan, who was nearly blind without the glasses he lost in the collision, Dove was killed after his gun was hit by a 223 slug and disabled, and Platt shot him to the ground, then blew his head off at close range. Ron Risner fired from across the street with little effect, and Mundo Mireles was nearly taken out by a 223 round that basically blew his forearm inside-out. Platt was the aggressor and used the stolen Mini-14 (full-auto) to take out seven agents. Few of the shotguns the FBI agents had ever came into play. It was the most thoroughly investigated shootout in history, surpassing the OK Corral mess, with many more tools used to explain how and why things went the way they did. (More info can be found here; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1986_FBI_Miami_shootout )

As earlier stated, the 9mm pistols were blamed, as the Feds claimed they were outgunned. The 10mm was suggested as a replacement, and several years and millions of dollars were expended in the quest for the ultimate handgun and round. The Ten was picked, but the guns were large and heavy and kicked like hell, and the smaller statured/female agents didn't like them, and couldn't shoot them well enough to qualify with them. There were also problem with the guns themselves, especially the 1076, as I recall.

While all that was going on, other factions decided to experiment with a shorter version of the 10mm case, and it was quickly realized that a 40-caliber round the same length as the 9mm could be adapted to existing guns quickly, as the feed geometry didn't have to be altered much. The new .40S&W round was announced in early 1990, and guns were available a scant few months later, most notably Glock and S&W. Every pistol-maker on the planet scrambled to chamber the new wunderkind, and before another year had passed you could get the 40 Smith & Wesson (or 40 Short & Weak, depending on who you listened to) in just about any semi-auto ever made.

The Ten Millimeter was popularized by one Lt Col. John "Jeff" Cooper, whose input led to the design of the Bren Ten, a somewhat modified version of the CZ-75, a pistol that Cooper liked in spite of its chambering in 9mm. Cooper was not fond of the "Crunchentickers" as he called the DA Autos of the day, but in a strengthened gun he championed it. He also had some input into the design of the 10mm round, and claimed it had as much energy at 200 yards as his beloved 45ACP had at the muzzle. Upon reading that, back in the 80's, I marveled at the mind that could conceive it, the gun that could contain it, and the men who could shoot it "properly". I vowed to become one. :embarassed:

Fast forward to present day: The 40S&W, once the perfect "Compromise" caliber with good ballistics that split the difference between the mag capacity of the 9mm and the more effective ballistics of the 45ACP, is now on the downslide as police agencies continue to seek the perfect balance between training costs and effectiveness. Even the FBI, which once championed bigger calibers, has now decided the 9mm is "good enough", while other agencies have gone to the 10mm (rarely) and sometimes the 45ACP in guns that hold a lot of bullets. The 9mm, ballistically, has gotten better, and costs a lot less to train with. When money is tight, the first thing that police agencies cut is training (stupid, but still true!) and the 9mm is now finding a home in a lot of jurisdictions that eagerly glommed onto the 40S&W when it came out. Times change, yet administrative thinking never does.

The Ten Millimeter still has a following, some would give it Cult Status but it's become more than that.....hunters and outdoorsmen use and love it, but there is also a strong contingent of people who believe that if something is worth shooting, it's worth shooting it HARD, and the 10 does that. When penetration is needed, I can't think of a round that does it better. 200, even 220 grain bullets will push through an awful lot of anything when fired from a 5-6 inch barrel, and new 10mm models are being introduced regularly.

As for the 40, I chose it over the 9mm, because those are my only two choices for on-duty carry, and I would much rather have Better bullets than More bullets. If I ever have to shoot someone, on or off duty, I want them to give up the fight after one solid hit, rather than half a dozen. The 9mm might be better than it use to be, but the 40 and the 10 have ALWAYS been better at ending things faster.

And just to be clear, when I get off duty and take off my 40.........I put on a 45. :bandit:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
142 Posts
I have a Ruger P944 ,just like the OP. I got it for cheap. It is used and it is a rugged tank. 180 grain bullets are super comfortable to shoot because I think the gun weighs 40 oz. ? 155 grain has some kick . Great gun . Mine was ex-leo like the one in the attached Ruger advertisement from the 1990's.
Good companion gun for a 40 carbine like the PC4
 

Attachments

·
Banned
Joined
·
4,647 Posts
OK, I have to ask - any opinions/experiences with the HiPoint 1095 10mm carbine? I have their 995 and 4095 carbines, and they're a hoot. Very reliable and boringly accurate. I can't help but think the 1095 would be even better. It'll likely be my next gun purchase.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
18,009 Posts
No personal experience with the 1095 here, but every review I've seen has been positive, including the ones from folks who really wanted to hate on the gun just because of the name. But when the smoke cleared they grudgingly admitted they liked it. Were it not for the proprietary magazines, Hi-point would easily sell at least twice as many guns. I'm one of the folks who would happily buy one of it took Glock mags. :bandit:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
209 Posts
Ok, so here's a question I've had for a while.....

Does the Glock 20, and the 10mm cartridge really fair better against big bruins than the Ol' Trustworthy S&W M29, and the .44 Mag?
Now, I know the Glock 20 has more rounds, that's a given. But is under powered next to the .44 Mag. If you get a good .44 cal 240 gr bullet zipping out at 1250fps +, that's a lot of steam behind just one bullet.

What sayeth the forum?
Just curious.

Sent from my motorola one using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
209 Posts
To me, a 10mm is close to a .41 Mag, not quite, but closer to a .41 Mag than a .357 Mag.
The .40, to me has as much power as a .357 Mag, with the lighter 155 gr or 165 gr bullets, or it exceeds a .357 just a little with handloads.
The .357 can be a little snappy, just like a .40 is.
Before I started shooting the .40 in the Academy, I shot .357, .41, and .44 Mags.
The .357, I found, was very manageable, the .41 a little stouter, but quite manageable, and the .44 Mag could be a complete beast with certain loads, and hurt quite a bit with certain loads.
The .40, to me, is every bit as controllable as a .357, in my opinion.
Now, I know, if you're used to a 9mm, and you work up to a .40, it can be a little daunting, because it does recoil more. The trick is to not have a death grip on the handle. Try using more of a firm handshake grip, and let the recoil naturally go up. You'll feel a lot better after you use this technique.

Sent from my motorola one using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,605 Posts
I wish the ruger PC was in .357 Sig or 10mm or 45 Super. My ultimate would be a 41 mag with the rim turned down to run in an auto and stack in a mag. That would be my ultimate do all.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,800 Posts
I just finished a project where I took a Series 70 Colt Govt in 9mm with a Std 5 in slide and fitted it with a 9mm Fusion 6inch 9mm slide. There was quite a bit of fitting that had to be done inclusive of fitting a new thumb safety and lower barrel lug fitting. The slide was a very tight fit on my Series 70 frame and had to be hand fit using a slide rail file. I just tested it at the range and it functions perfect using Blazer 9mm aluminum case ammo with a 14 lbs spring. Now---I'm going to try phase 2 and fit a 40 S&W slide\barrel to the same frame as the ejector and slide release on a 9mm fram are the same for 40 S&W. The only reason for having to buy a 40 slide is for the slightly larger cartridge head of the 40. I hope I don't need to fit a new thumb safety for the 40 cal slide as the notch in the slide may not line up depending on lockup after barrel fitting. Of course 40 cal 1911 mags will need to be obtained for that mod.
My original Colt slide with barrel and thumb safety goes back on as no mods are done to it so it can be restored back to original---no permanent changes were done to the original frame.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gunscrewguy

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,190 Posts
Ok, so here's a question I've had for a while.....

Does the Glock 20, and the 10mm cartridge really fair better against big bruins than the Ol' Trustworthy S&W M29, and the .44 Mag?
Now, I know the Glock 20 has more rounds, that's a given. But is under powered next to the .44 Mag. If you get a good .44 cal 240 gr bullet zipping out at 1250fps +, that's a lot of steam behind just one bullet.

What sayeth the forum?
Just curious.

Sent from my motorola one using Tapatalk
The 44 magnum is a much more powerful and effective cartridge for protection from large bears. I would rate the 10mm as barely adequate but what it has going for it is you can carry it much more comfortably. I would feel better armed with a hot 357 load instead to be honest. 460 rowland would be the ticket IMO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,775 Posts
Given adequate bullets and velocity to get a job done, most of "effectiveness" often depends upon the efficiency of the cartridge and pistol to get the required energy on target fast. Personally I can get six accurate hits from a hot 10 mm on a target in the same time it takes to get 2 or possibly 3 hot 44 mags hits on target. That maybe 1800/2700 lb of energy on target from a 44 but about 3700 lb from a 10mm, don't even think it is a fair comparison.
 
21 - 40 of 41 Posts
Top