Not too much trouble here. Compared to Fiocchi brass, PPU is the best made. I think most of my .30-30 brass is Remington and Winchester.
Marlins: 1951 336RC .30-30 - 1951 39A "Peanut" - 1988 Model 60 (22" blued) - 1982 783 22WMR
Bangin' Blackhawks Member #30 Team .22 Mag Member #69 Team 30-30 Member #1328 Team Rossi #77
GM World Class Technician since 2003
I recently tried to convert some mixed .223 brass to 300 blackout and now have 40 pieces of the 250 that will not chamber in my rifle. After pulling them back apart, I found that the brass of the PPU cases is thicker by 0.003 to 0.005 and thereby increased the outside neck diameter enough that it would not chamber. Lesson learned. I decided it wasn't worth the effort to neck turn the brass to save $2 worth of primers.
I'd say, reduce the charge and work up. Then keep the PPU brass separate.
Your reputation is what men say about you on your tombstone, your character is what the angels proclaim about you before the throne of God!
GITU1, Matt my buddy who works with me on the weekends is a precision engineer, I ran it past him when we were toping up the Pheasant feeders only 90 sacks today. As the neck diameter of loaded cases was the same he reckoned cheap brass and the mix is to hard maybe to much nickel. As I have 200 of the dam things I will anneal a few, just seat a few bullets in empty cases and see what they are like to pull. If they are any easier (less neck tension) I will work up a new load. I will look again at neck thickness and make a call, I would sooner scrap the lot than turn 200 necks. I will update on how it turns out. Gar.
If PPU brass is thicker than other brands that equates to less case capacity thus higher pressure with a like load that is charged into thinner brass. Higher pressures with PPU would exacerbate brass neck sticking as well.
Instead of weighing the brass to find case capacity it would be much more accurate to to weigh the brass, fill it with water to a comparable measurement and compare to a brass that has been working for you. I suspect case capacity is the culprit. 30-30 is loaded to a higher pressure in European factory loads thus the thicker brass
Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves.” — William Pitt (the Younger), Speech in the House of Commons, November 18, 1783
Bryan, the PPU brass holds 6 more grains of water that the win brass. I am half way through turning the case necks, I measured the Win case necks.009 - .011 th, I am turning the PPU to .010 th, the thing is the PPU brass was NOT thicker than some of the win brass. I will then anneal and take it from there. I will say again I have never had any bullet in any calibre so hard to pull as the PPU cases. After annealing I am going to seat a couple of bullets and pull them without loading any powder or seating a primer just to see what neck tension I now have. Gareth.
SI VIS PACEM--PARA BELLUM
WHAT WE THINK WE BECOME