Good Evening to All, but especially those lucky enough to have and shoot a Marlin 1894 in .41 mag.
I'm hoping that next deer season I'll be able utilize my CCL .41 mag and help fill my whitetail tags. My question concerns bullet selection. I'd like to use Hornady's 210 gr. XTP, but am concerned if it will give the penetration necessary for a quick, humane kill or (heaven forbid!) a good blood trail.
Thus far, I've only used this bullet on varmints (armadillos, coons, and occasionally a possum). The results with this bullet have been nothing short REALLY IMPRESSIVE! Muzzle velocity is +/-1,775 fps. (actual chronograph readings, no guesstimates) and inside of 50 yds., armadillos literally explode. The others sustain EXTREME soft tissue damage to say the least.
I'm thinking that the velocity I'm getting from the rifle exceeds the tolerances of the XTP bullet - after all, that is a handgun bullet. Have any of you used the 210 gr. XTP on whitetails and if so, what's your impression?
I do have a couple of other choices to include a Rem 210 gr. SP at basically the same velocity or a cast 220 gr. RNFP at +/-1,550 fps., but that XTP is so darned accurate in my rifle I'd like to use it.
So - based on your experiences, will the XTP do the job?
Thanks in advance.
Can never have too many;
1895xlr, 1894cs, 1894css, 1894ltdss, 338mxlr, 336ss, 336gbl, 336cs, 39a, 36a
And still looking for more...
My only kill with a 41 was several years with a BH and a 210 gr cast.
Around 25 yds, it was a complete pass through and she never took another step.
I have a Henry 41 mag and plan to hunt some with it this next year also.
I'll be using a heavy cast bullet this time also.
I have no experience with that XTP bullet.
Like the above posted have used the 240 XTP 44.
I noticed we are practically neighbors.
Monty Walsh "You have No idea how little I care".
The Hornady manual states the max velocity for the 210g XTP is 1450 fps . I use 19.5g of Hodgdon H110 with good results (accuracy) in my Henry BBS. I'm afraid above their specs I wouldn't get the penetration I needed if need be, For my Ruger BHH I use 210g Speer Deep Curl and Hodgdon HS-6 (1300 fps) which is very accurate and little recoil. Hope this helps you out.
I have found the 210 grain XTP very accurate in my .41 magnum FG, like you did. My load is alo in the 1775 fps range. I would take a heart/lung shot shot with no worry. I would try to avoid a dead on shoulder shot. It would do the job, I've done it with my Blackhawk, but that is running a little slower and mushrooms quite a bit on heavy bone. Hard cast drills whitetail shoulder bones very well on the other hand.
It's what you learn after you know it all that makes a difference.
xtp will get the job done and if you cast mp molds 640-413 looks real good
On game, bullet performance is far more important than the last word in accuracy. It has been a long time, but the Rem SP, performs very much like the 44 mag 240 gr SP, which is to say ideal.
"Should have put more dirt down, saw it right off." Bear Claw in Jeremiah Johnson
I use a 240 xtp in my muzzleloader to good effect; I've no reason to believe it won't be effective in your 41 mag. Hornady makes good stuff.
I owe my life to an organ donor.
I have killed alot of deer with my FG. Either one will work just fine. IF you know the deer will be big & IF you know the range will be short, the Rem. SP has an edge.
Team 444 #322
Team old Pharts # 18