If you were going to have (1) lever action which one would you buy?
I know the 30-30 ammunition is easier to find but it seems there is allot of love for the 35 remington.
I hunt in South Texas and will use it some for deer and hogs.
I hunt mostly with scoped rifles for trophies but after that the fun begins with culls and does.
It looks as though there are some clean 35 remingtons for sale around $300.
I will either put a Skinner Sight on it or a 2.5x7x32 scope.
Of the two choices given, I'd go with the 35 and not look back.
Now, if I truly had to limit myself to just one, I'd go with the 444.
"A free people (claim) their rights as derived from the laws of nature, and not as the gift of their chief magistrate."
--Thomas Jefferson, Rights of British America, 1774
Team 60 #21
Team 35 #8
Team 444 #13
Team 45-70 #14
Team 30-30 #152
Team Shotgun #23
Team Browning #43
Marlins = Lays Potato Chips ...Originally Posted by snuffy1
A clean .35 Rem for around $300 is a real bargain in this area.
I'll say with the .30-30. Never seen one fail to anchor a deer or hog.
I have owned Marlins in .35 Remington, and every time, I would up selling them.
Nemo Me Impune Lacesset
May the Bonnie Blue wave forever
I've played this game! My first Marlin was a .35rem 336A, I didn't reload at the time and the ammo cost was significant. I've got 2 30-30's now, factory ammo is somewhat reasonable and reloading the 30-30 is pretty cheap fun. I'll always have a 30-30.
"What's my favorite rifle? The one I'm shooting."
Team 30-30 #312
If you want easier to find and cheaper ammo get the .30-30, if you want the superior riffle get the 35 Remington.
ASE Master certified engine machinist
Team .30-30 #234
Team .35 #159
Team .45-70 #161
Team 1894 #30
Team 39 #40
Team 444 #357
Team .32 SPECIAL #3
Team 60 #8
Team 450 #89
Team 35 Member #3
Gave my 30/30 to my son after owning, reloading & shooting my 35 Rem.
We have a thread like this every now and then because we are always getting new members who haven't been parties to the other threads.
Frankly, I think it boils down to a matter of personal preferance. If I had to make a choice between the two, I would pick the .35 Remington. But, to tell the truth, anything I could kill with a .35, I could probably kill just as dead with a .30-30. As a matter of fact, I have a number of each, and I like both chamberings pretty well. I'm a handloader, so cost of ammunition is not really a factor for me.
"Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other." --John Adams
Just 1, then I'd have to go with the .30-30. It will accomplish everything a .35 will on deer and hogs and ammo is more abundant. If I were you, I'd do my best to own several of each!
Yes, $300 would be considered a very good price on a clean.35 around here. They're usually closer to the $400 mark.
"We cannot but pity the boy who has never fired a gun; he is no more humane, while his education has been sadly neglected". - Thoreau