I saw the Mar-Shield finish today for the 1st time on a few newer 336's. Good gawd it was fugly. What the hale were they thinkin Of course I thought it looked better than the laminate finish XLR I saw.... I much prefer the finish on the older guns. I guess I'm old school and set in my ways....
"Courage is what it takes to stand up and speak. Courage is also what it takes to sit down and listen"- Winston Churchill
Yep, looks like sprayed on thinned brown paint IMO, give me a nice clear finish on a piece of walnut anyday. If I were to buy a new one the first thing to go would be the finish. Mr fixit
Team 444 Co-Captain
Member #168 1994 444SS
Team 45/70--- #23 2009 1895CB
Team 1894-----# 301 2001 45LC CB
Team 39------- #41 2004 39A
Team 60------- # 22 60SB, 60SS, Model 65 "Golden 50"
Marlin League-- #18
"The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government."-----Thomas Jefferson
Hunting - It's a matter of national security.
Even back in the early 70's the Marshield finish was ghastly. I guess when you spray on the finish that's how it's going to look. I much prefer the ones I have refinished. Of course other gun makers have had some ghastly finishes over the years, as well.
The Older I Get...The Better I was...
Team 444 Member #175
Team 35 Member #2
Team 39 Member #10
Marlin League #26
338 MX...It's not your father's lever action!
Ghastly is an understatement, Hal, but you must admit it is tough and durable yet easily repaired when scratched. For a beautiful finish, nothing can compare to a good hand rubbed oil finish. So one must choose, tough or beauty. All depends on how the gun will be used.
I like Mar-Shield. I save it when I can. I've had very good luck repairing it.
The Mar shield on my336SS and 1985GS Don't look to bad. I know I could put on A better finish but afraid to screw up the checkering. Mabye after A few dings I will get my courage up and put on A proper finish.
Blessed is he who expects nothing for he shall not be disapointed
LT, you are quite correct, the Marshield finish is UGLY. It is also very cheap to apply and that is why it is used. A nice hand rubbed oil finish would be nice but then the price would be outragious. Refinishing our marlins is part of Marlinitis. I know my new 444 has walnut stock and fore end, but plain grain and the Marshield makes it worse. Someday I'll strip the old finish off and put on a hand rubbed oil finish, that will highlight any grain there and be very nice. Y'all take care, John.
Just keep on keeping on.
It's not what you do, it's how you do what you do, that counts.
Old age and treachery will overcome youth and skills.
What exactly is a "better" or "proper" finish? As I said, the Mar-shield is tough and durable. It's also very easily repaired. What are you going to use that is more durable, repairable, and care free? Pretty it is not, so do you want a beautiful safe queen or an ugly hunting rifle that can take abuse?Originally Posted by Gaterskiner
Keep in mind that Mar-Shield is waterproof. Oil finishes aren't. Also keep in mind that a stock refinish hurts the resale value of your gun.
It was said that the Mar-Shield can be easily repaired.How do you repair it and to what degree of damage is repairable?